2022 Pennsylvania Governor Voters Guide

Doug Mastriano (R) vs Josh Shapiro (D)

Governor | Election | Nov 8, 2022

The Candidates

Doug Mastriano

Doug Mastriano

Republican

Josh Shapiro

Josh Shapiro

Democrat

The Issues

Abortion

Ban or legal?

Doug Mastriano (R)

Ban. Proposed a bill in the PA Senate banning abortion once “heartbeat” is detected (usually at six weeks), with no exception for rape, incest, or the life of the mother. “If the baby has a heartbeat, the abortion cannot be performed.”

Click To Share Stance

Climate Change

Should climate change be a top priority? Tax or limit the output of greenhouse gases, or support renewable energy?

Click To Share Stance

Education

How to address the teaching of issues around race and gender identity?

Josh Shapiro (D)

No position found.

Use public funding for private and/or for-profit schools?

Doug Mastriano (R)

Yes. “Administrative bloat has become commonplace” in PA public schools. Wants to expand scholarship programs so parents can choose public or private schools.

Josh Shapiro (D)
Click To Share Stance

Environment

Loosen or tighten environmental regulations?

Doug Mastriano (R)

Loosen. Would cut statewide regulations in order to expand fracking and the coal industry.

Click To Share Stance

Gun Laws

Pass less or more restrictive legislation on guns?

Josh Shapiro (D)

More. Supports universal background checks, closing the ghost-gun loophole, and red-flag laws, which allow courts to remove guns from people deemed to pose a threat.

Click To Share Stance

Health Care

Increase government role in health care, such as expanding Medicaid, limiting drug prices, or promoting COVID safety?

Click To Share Stance

Labor

Make it easier or harder for unions to organize?

Doug Mastriano (R)

Harder. Would make PA a right-to-work state, where employees in a unionized workplace are allowed to not pay union dues, which can lessen the union’s resources.

Click To Share Stance

Police and Community

How to aHow to address police use of force?

Click To Share Stance

Student Financial Aid

Support lowering interest on student loans or forgiving them?

Doug Mastriano (R)

No position found.

Josh Shapiro (D)
Click To Share Stance

Taxes

Should corporations pay less or more taxes?

Click To Share Stance

Share the 2022 Pennsylvania Governor Voters Guide

We have space to include only candidates polling 15% or more. But check out others including Matt Hackenburg (L) and Joe Soloski (K).

guides.vote is a nonpartisan effort to show where candidates stand, with links to credible sources. We do not support or oppose any political party or candidate for office. Vote411.org offers guides to local races.

×
Candidate Image

Doug Mastriano

republican Party

Candidate Image

Josh Shapiro

democratic Party

Download Image
guides.vote
guides.vote

Doug Mastriano

republican

Josh Shapiro

democratic

See guides.vote for online guides with links & sources https://www.doug4gov.com/ https://joshshapiro.org/
Abortion

Ban or legal?

Ban. Proposed a bill in the PA Senate banning abortion once “heartbeat” is detected (usually at six weeks), with no exception for rape, incest, or the life of the mother. “If the baby has a heartbeat, the abortion cannot be performed.”Legal. Will “veto any bill restricting abortion rights…will expand access to reproductive care.” Filed brief challenging the legality of banning abortion at 15 weeks.  “I trust the women of Pennsylvania to make decisions about their own bodies.”
Climate Change

Should climate change be a top priority? Tax or limit the output of greenhouse gases, or support renewable energy?

No. Global warming is not real; it’s “fake science.” How can we “believe what [the weatherman] says for a hundred years from now?” Will take PA out of Regional Greenhouse Gas initiative on day one.Yes. We need to take real action to address climate change.” Has concerns about Governor Wolf’s carbon tax plan but wants to “chart a path towards a low carbon future” by investing in renewable energy and carbon capture.
Education

How to address the teaching of issues around race and gender identity?

Would place “an immediate ban on Critical Race Theory and Gender Theory studies.” “On day one, CRT is over.”No position found.
Elections

Did Joe Biden legitimately win the 2020 Presidential election?

No. The election in PA was “compromised.” Organized and funded buses to the DC January 6 rally and attended himself. Calls his subpoena from the US House January 6 Committee a “badge of honor.”Yes. “We had a free and fair, safe and secure election, and as attorney general, I… stood up to the attempts to undermine our democracy.”
Environment

Loosen or tighten environmental regulations?

Loosen. Would cut statewide regulations in order to expand fracking and the coal industry.Tighten. Criminally charged fracking companies for repeated pollution violations. Seeks “stronger laws to hold…companies accountable.”
Gun Laws

Pass less or more restrictive legislation on guns?

Less. Cosponsored a bill to prevent PA officials from enforcing any new federal gun restrictions. “We saw Hitler do the same thing in Germany.” Also cosponsored a bill to allow concealed gun-carry without a license or permit.More. Supports universal background checks, closing the ghost-gun loophole, and red-flag laws, which allow courts to remove guns from people deemed to pose a threat.
Health Care

Increase government role in health care, such as expanding Medicaid, limiting drug prices, or promoting COVID safety?

No. Would ban any government mask mandates, calling for restoring supporters’ “private personal freedom.” Sought the suspension of federal medical privacy rules for individuals in the face of the pandemic.Yes. Defended the Affordable Care Act as a “vital safety net” in “the midst of a resurgent COVID-19 pandemic.” In 2021 asked the PA Supreme Court to keep the state’s school mask mandate in place.
Immigration

How to handle immigration? Support a path to citizenship for “DACA” participants brought to the US as children?

Supports a border wall and sending PA National Guard to the Mexican border. Opposes sanctuary cities. “We’re going to put these DACA lawbreakers ahead of all these good people…trying to come here legally....They should not become citizens. They need to go back home.”Supports DACA, for PA youth brought to the US illegally as children. “Dreamers are Americans.” Supports comprehensive immigration reform.
Labor

Make it easier or harder for unions to organize?

Harder. Would make PA a right-to-work state, where employees in a unionized workplace are allowed to not pay union dues, which can lessen the union’s resources.Easier. “Pennsylvania workers…deserve a Governor who will…not only protect the right to organize, but expand it, so…every worker has the opportunity to join a union.”
LGBTQ Rights

Limit or expand LGBTQ rights?

Limit. Gay marriage should not be legal; “I’m for traditional marriage.” Gender identity should “absolutely not” be added to anti-discrimination laws. LGBTQ couples should not be allowed to adopt.Expand. “Expand Pennsylvania’s hate crime law to include crimes against our LGBTQ+ people. That’s something that I sponsored when I was in the house.”
Marijuana

Should recreational marijuana be banned or legal?

Ban. Legalization causes an increase in violence, mental illness, and driving under the influence. “It’s just madness and stupid.”Legal. Legalization will “bring billions of dollars to Pennsylvania.” “Expunge the records of those serving time for non-violent marijuana convictions.”
Minimum Wage

Keep or raise the state minimum from $7.25 per hour? If raise, how much?

Keep. A minimum wage increase would be a “death knell” to small businesses. Economic drivers should decide “the right wage for the right area.”Raise. “We need...nothing less than [a] 15-dollar minimum wage.”Pennsylvania’s minimum wage is $7.25.... under the federal poverty line. Every working Pennsylvanian deserves a living wage.”
Police and Community

How to aHow to address police use of force?

No position found on use of force. Supports increased police funding.Supported a 2020 law that requires law enforcement agencies to consult a statewide police database with access to any misconduct and disciplinary records of officers that they're seeking to hire.
Student Financial Aid

Support lowering interest on student loans or forgiving them?

No position found.Likely yes. Co-led litigation in a lawsuit with 39 attorneys general that resulted in the cancellation of $1.7 billion in student loan balances at a major student loan servicer.
Taxes

Should corporations pay less or more taxes?

Less. Will attract “new employers to PA by reducing the Corporate Net Income Tax Rate.”Mixed. Will lower corporate net income tax, while closing tax loopholes.
Voting Rules

Support tightened restrictions on such voting rules as absentee and early voting, and voter ID?

Yes. Will eliminate no-excuse mail-in voting and ballot drop boxes, and enact universal voter ID. Will delete PA voter rolls and make all voters re-register to vote.No. Will “expand early voting and set up automatic voter registration.” Will “veto any efforts to restrict mail-in voting.” Is willing to discuss voter ID “in good faith.”

Success!

×
Download Images