2024 Michigan Supreme Court Voter Guide

General Election

To download a PDF of this guide in English, click here,

Two seats on the Michigan Supreme Court are up for election in 2024. This race is a general election for an open seat on the Court, for a full eight-year term, to replace Republican-nominated Justice David Viviano, who is retiring. The candidates are nominated by their state parties, but the positions are nonpartisan, and candidates are listed without a party affiliation. The two candidates are State Rep. Andrew Fink, nominated by the Republicans, and law professor Kimberly Ann Thomas, nominated by the Democrats. The other race is for a partial term. Democratic justices currently have a 4-3 majority on the Court. Their majority will grow to five if Democrats win both races. Republicans will gain a 4-3 majority if Republicans win both.

Michigan Supreme Court decisions can have big consequences:

To help you decide, we’ve assembled background about the candidates’ education and previous work experience—along with public statements, publicized endorsements, and rulings they’ve made if they’re sitting judges—to indicate how they might rule on key issues in the future.

Judicial candidates often have fewer public positions on key issues. We include only the positions we can find that match our standard list of topics. Different candidates often address different topics.

The Issues

Thomas Fink
Andrew Fink
Kimberly Ann Thomas
Kimberly Thomas

Drew Fink (Republican)

Andrew Fink is a Republican nominee and state representative from the 35th District. First elected to the state House in 2020, he currently serves as the Republican vice-chair of the House Judiciary Committee. He earned his law degree from the University of Michigan Law School in 2010 after graduating from Hillsdale College. After law school, he worked as a judge advocate for the U.S. Marine Corps. In 2014, he joined his family’s law firm, Fink & Fink, where he practiced civil litigation, property law, municipal law, and probate litigation. He is a member of the NRA, the American Legion, and the Federalist Society, considered a dominant force in promoting conservative and libertarian-leaning judges.

Fink is endorsed by state representatives, county sheriffs, and prosecutors; US Congressmen John Moolenaar and Tim Walberg; former Michigan Gov. John Engler; the Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC), and others.


Kimberly Thomas (Democrat)

Kimberly Ann Thomas is a Democratic nominee and a professor at the University of Michigan Law School. She runs the Juvenile Justice Clinic, representing people who cannot afford a lawyer. She served on the bipartisan Michigan Task Force on Juvenile Justice Reform, which proposed recommendations to improve outcomes for young people, including expanded opportunities for youth to avoid the formal legal system. She earned her law degree from Harvard University after graduating from the University of Maryland, College Park, and was a Fulbright Scholar. Before joining the Michigan Law School faculty, Thomas was a trial attorney with Defender Association of Philadelphia, which provides public defense services to low-income Philadelphians.

  • On abortion, Thomas said she could not take a position as a judicial candidate, but would consider the legislative and constitutional basis before deciding on an issue that protects or restricts rights. The court “has to respect all the other branches of government and the decisions and expertise that exists.” She lists endorsements by three abortion rights advocacy groups on her website.
  • On law enforcement and racial bias, in a commentary she co-authored with two others, Thomas said the presence of police officers in public schools can lead to “criminalizing… behavior that is “developmentally normal and appropriate.” That criminalization is based on “officer perception,” which can be “influenced by racial bias.” School-based officers have often targeted students “who ‘made adults mad,’ not students who were dangerous.” 
  • On juvenile justice, she advocated for legislation that would prohibit young people from waiving their right to counsel unless they were advised on the consequences of doing so. When young people understand what’s going on, “they can make choices for themselves, they can have their voices heard—and that’s really important.”
  • On access to justice, Thomas said her experience representing low-income people and teaching students has given her a commitment to “ensure that each litigant is heard and respected.”

Thomas is endorsed by Reproductive Freedom for All, Michigan AFL-CIO, Young Democrats of Michigan, Women Lawyers Association of Michigan, Emily’s List, Planned Parenthood Advocates of Michigan, and others.


guides.vote is a nonpartisan effort to show where candidates stand. We do not support or oppose any political party or candidate. We include candidates polling 15% or more including links to credible sources and other candidates. Vote411.org offers guides to local races and how to vote. For campuses, see Campus Vote Project’s state-specific guides to student voting rules.

×
Candidate Image

Andrew Fink

republican Party

Candidate Image

Kimberly Thomas

democrat Party

Download Image